Non Toxic Teething Toys: 15+ Best Baby-Safe Picks for 2025
When your baby starts teething, it can feel like a whole new parenting level—drool, fussiness, and the desperate need to chew on everything. That’s where non toxic teething toys come in.
They’re designed to provide safe relief for sore gums without exposing your baby to harmful chemicals like BPA, phthalates, and PVC.
In this guide, we’ll explore the best non toxic teething toys you can trust in 2025. These toys are baby-safe, parent-approved, and many are even backed by pediatricians.
We’ve included options for every preference—natural rubber, wooden, silicone, or cooling teethers.
🔍 Looking for mold-free bath toys too? Check out our full list of safe and mold-free bath toys for babies that pair perfectly with these teethers.
This post may contain affiliate links. Full privacy policy and disclosure here.
Why Choose Non Toxic Teething Toys?
Babies explore the world with their mouths, and when teething starts, chewing becomes instinctive. But not all toys are created equal. Many mass-market teethers are made with materials that can leach chemicals when chewed—especially when exposed to saliva or heat.
Choosing non toxic teething toys ensures:
- No exposure to BPA, PVC, or phthalates
- Safer chewing and gnawing
- Materials like 100% natural rubber, food-grade silicone, or organic wood
- Peace of mind for parents
The 15 Best Non Toxic Teething Toys (2025 Picks)
Here are the best teething toys that meet safety standards, soothe sore gums, and are loved by babies and parents alike.
1. Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether
- Material: 100% medical-grade silicone
- Why we love it: Lightweight, easy for tiny hands, dishwasher-safe
- Bonus: Mimics baby fingers for a familiar feel
2. Sophie la Girafe Natural Rubber Teether
- Material: Natural Hevea rubber
- Why we love it: Iconic design, soothing texture, squeaks for fun
- Safety: Painted with food-grade paint
✨ Want more ways to calm a fussy baby? Read: 5 Genius Teething Toys That Instantly Soothe Fussy Babies
3. Boon Pulp Silicone Feeder
- Material: BPA-free silicone
- Why we love it: Great for chilled fruits like banana or cucumber
- Double-duty: It’s a feeder and a teether
4. Eco-Friendly Wooden and Silicone Ring Teether
- Material: Beechwood + food-grade silicone
- Why we love it: Natural and biodegradable
- Pro tip: Always check for splinters before use
5. RaZbaby RaZberry Silicone Teether
- Material: 100% medical-grade silicone
- Why we love it: Looks like a raspberry, textured for gum massage
- Bonus: Can be chilled for extra relief
6. Green Sprouts Cooling Teether
- Material: EVA & purified water
- Why we love it: Ideal for cooling teething relief
- Safety: PVC-free, no synthetic gels
7. Mombella Elephant Teether
- Material: BPA-free silicone
- Why we love it: Fun elephant shape, soft and flexible
- Bonus: Can be used as a pacifier substitute
Materials to Look For in Non Toxic Teething Toys
Before clicking “add to cart,” make sure your toy checks these boxes:
- 100% food-grade silicone
- Natural rubber (like Hevea)
- Untreated wood (like maple or beech)
- No synthetic dyes or chemical smells
When in doubt, look for brands with third-party safety certifications (like CPSIA or EN71).
💡 Struggling with pacifier dependence during teething? Here’s what to do when your baby wakes up for a pacifier.
What About Teething Gels?
Sometimes teething toys alone aren’t enough—especially during those sleepless nights. If you’re considering a topical option, make sure it’s benzocaine-free (which the FDA warns against for infants).
We’ve rounded up the best teething gels for babies here—gentle, natural, and pediatrician-approved.
Extra Relief Tips for Teething Babies
While non toxic teething toys are your first line of defense, these strategies can help too:
- Chill (but don’t freeze) teething toys for added comfort
- Use clean fingers to gently massage gums
- Offer a cold washcloth for gnawing
- Create a calm bedtime routine to reduce irritability
- Try teething necklaces (for moms)—baby chews while snuggling
FAQ: Non Toxic Teething Toys
What are non toxic teething toys made of?
Most are made from food-grade silicone, natural rubber, or untreated wood. These materials are safe for chewing and free from harmful chemicals like BPA, phthalates, and PVC.
Are wooden teethers safe for babies?
Yes, if they’re made from smooth, untreated hardwood (like beech). Always inspect for cracks or rough edges and clean with a damp cloth—never soak.
Can I refrigerate or freeze teething toys?
You can refrigerate most silicone or water-filled teethers. Avoid freezing, as frozen toys can become too hard and may hurt your baby’s gums.
How often should I clean teething toys?
Daily! Silicone and rubber toys can usually be boiled or washed in the dishwasher. Wooden toys should be wiped down with a damp cloth and dried immediately.
When should I replace a teething toy?
Replace if you notice cracks, tears, or signs of wear. Most manufacturers recommend swapping out teething toys every few months, depending on use.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Teether
Teething can be tough—but with the right tools, it doesn’t have to be miserable for your baby (or for you). Choosing non toxic teething toys is a small decision that brings huge peace of mind. Your little one can chew, drool, and soothe their gums safely—and maybe even sleep better.
Looking for a thoughtful baby shower gift? Pair a non-toxic teether with a mold-free bath toy and a gentle teething gel to make the ultimate baby care bundle.
📌 Save for Later
Don’t forget to pin this post to your baby gear board or share with a friend who has a teething baby! 👶🦷